Jump to content

on "push" mechanic


alre
 Share

Recommended Posts

  Quote

Well I can't hold habituation against you. But ultra dense unit packing does cause problems for gameplay and balance:

  1. Choke points have less gameplay impact. This limits the ability of map designers to finesse away certain balance issues, and reduces gameplay diversity. (See this situation for an example of choke points not working: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPuNEQEomGQ&t=2229s).
Expand  

Less but not none, because moving units can't cross through non-moving units, so chokepoint can remain relatively crowded and ultimately impassable. And their ability to be turtled and ranged by more units remain

Also, conversely, artificial choke points because of bad pathfinding feel terrible.

  Quote
  1. It also reduces combat readability and control, which makes it harder to used mixed unit compositions effectively and reduces opportunities for players to distinguish themselves with individual unit micro.
Expand  

That is a good point, but the mosh pit design that we had already made this somewhat difficult.

---

Overall, I agree that the pushing feature can and should ideally be tweaked and improved, but I believe the good offsets the bad. We'll see how people feel in testing.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 05/06/2021 at 10:03 PM, ChronA said:

Choke points have less gameplay impact. This limits the ability of map designers to finesse away certain balance issues, and reduces gameplay diversity. (See this situation for an example of choke points not working: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPuNEQEomGQ&t=2229s).

Expand  

True, but choke points only working because of bad unit movement and pathfinding seems also bad to me :D From my point of view, choke point are restrictive, not because only few units can pass is, but because you can realistically block it with wall and palisades.

  On 05/06/2021 at 10:03 PM, ChronA said:

Same story with attack surface-area and concavity.

Expand  

Well but for which attacks do you need surface-area? Not sure if I understand your point. Do you think catapults will be too strong because they can theoretically affect more units with their splash damage?

  On 05/06/2021 at 10:03 PM, ChronA said:

It also reduces combat readability and control, which makes it harder to used mixed unit compositions effectively and reduces opportunities for players to distinguish themselves with individual unit micro.

Expand  

True, but that depends if people use formations or not. Also I'm not a fan of individual micro, so my opinion is very biased here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good news still on this front: I've increased the flexibility of the system so you can play with 3 more settings, and fixed an issue so it's possible to have units push each other more, so things should death ball _less_. See https://code.wildfiregames.com/D4098 which I've merged.

I'll still take player input during Feature Freeze, but I expect these new settings will be overall more satisfactory.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@wraithii

:) I appreciate your dedication, and based on their description the new parameters seem like great additions to the tool kit. I must tell you though that, in my testing, the new dials aren't producing much of a noticeable effect for me. I've even tired turning everything up to double digits, and while a few units on the edge of my groups have begun wandering around where otherwise they would remain stationary, as a group they are pretty much behaving just as before. The only parameter with a clear effect is Clearance.

Forgive me for asking, but in your own testing are you sure the pushing feature is working as you intended? I think by far the most likely explanation for these discrepancies is that I managed to corrupt my test installation somehow; but there's an the off chance I might be helping you find a bug... So I thought I'd better speak up ^_^

Edit: Actually looking at your screen shots on the diff, there is very clearly something not working right with my installation. I'm having teething problems with using SVN it seems. Pay me no mind. :P

Edited by ChronA
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

With this feature soldiers move much more smootly, meaning that in those situations where you would use formations in a24 to smooth out your men, you don't need anymore. On the other hand, formations still move in a clumsy and rigid way that loses a lot of time, and brings no advantage anymore.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Formations were exclusively used to position units and dance. Since formations do not change unit stats, like the effect of "phalanx", it is not a loss to the game.

It is still possible to use that one formation that puts healers in the middle which is obviously still useful. Also, players can still use a more manual approach to get effects in their fights. One time @Dizaka's ele spam was overcome by my border ally, and I think he ran out of metal ---> archie spam. I (with many metal mines) simply take 2 halves of my cav army and split early and converge on his archer ball and he is trapped.

I think smooth movement in general will be much more welcome as a replacement for the formations which were necessitated by the bad pathing of units in a24.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 06/06/2021 at 7:48 PM, ChronA said:

I appreciate your dedication, and based on their description the new parameters seem like great additions to the tool kit. I must tell you though that, in my testing, the new dials aren't producing much of a noticeable effect for me. I've even tired turning everything up to double digits, and while a few units on the edge of my groups have begun wandering around where otherwise they would remain stationary, as a group they are pretty much behaving just as before. The only parameter with a clear effect is Clearance.

Expand  

I think it's likely you didn't recompile? I should have specified this was necessary. Now there has been an auto build, so you should be able to tweak things.

It is definitely working for me, see the following comparison screenshots.

This is 2 groups of 100 units crossing each other's path at 0 extension, 2.5 extension,  5 extension, and then at 2.5 with lower MinPushing factors.

Copie de screenshot0038.pngCopie de screenshot0040.pngCopie de screenshot0044.pngCopie de screenshot0042.png

This is ordering these 200 units to go somewhere at 0/2.5/5

Copie de screenshot0039.pngCopie de screenshot0041.pngCopie de screenshot0045.png

 

Edit -> BTW, you can 'hotload' your changes by quick saving and quick loading.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 07/06/2021 at 5:10 AM, BreakfastBurrito_007 said:

Formations were exclusively used to position units and dance. Since formations do not change unit stats, like the effect of "phalanx", it is not a loss to the game.

It is still possible to use that one formation that puts healers in the middle which is obviously still useful. Also, players can still use a more manual approach to get effects in their fights. One time @Dizaka's ele spam was overcome by my border ally, and I think he ran out of metal ---> archie spam. I (with many metal mines) simply take 2 halves of my cav army and split early and converge on his archer ball and he is trapped.

I think smooth movement in general will be much more welcome as a replacement for the formations which were necessitated by the bad pathing of units in a24.

Expand  

There's the formation that puts healers in the middle.

There's also the formation that puts elephants in the front (they 'god-walk' through your own units).  Use this one when eles get stuck in the middle of units.

 

The formation that puts elephants in the front, coincidentally, also puts rams up front.  Rams, unlike eles, cannot attack units and/or farms.  Makes it frustrating with rams.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...