What about this??

[AlexHerbert]

I was playing with this guy and he got molested because I quitted but, reviewing the reply I noticed he has so much pop than the maximum.

Even with Wonder, he had 25+174+100+1=300 ?

What about this? @BreakfastBurrito_007 @Atrik  @Dunedan

And he said to me "pls be happy, I'm not a Smurf, I just have been playing longer than you" 

Edited 3 hours ago by AlexHerbert

[guerringuerrin]

I'm not using that mod but my guess is he had infantry champs and the panel is showing them on both columns Inf and Chp.
You can check the replay and select all his units to confirm

[Atrik]

Class counters aren't mutually exclusives in ModernGUI. Which indeed makes champion cavalry or infantry represented in both columns.
That's not a bug, that's also like this in the autociv panel for example, and it make sens.
But it gave me the idea to try to make things clearer by adding an a little spacer between champs and the rest, as it's the only column that a unit can be represented twice.

[Atrik]

[AlexHerbert]

Is not a ModernGUI bug or similar, autociv shows me the same. 

I'm so confused.

[Atrik]

4 minutes ago, AlexHerbert said:

Is not a ModernGUI bug or similar, autociv shows me the same. 

I'm so confused.

Sorry if that's confusing. Could you tell me if the spacer would have made it less confusing?

[guerringuerrin]

26 minutes ago, Atrik said:

Class counters aren't mutually exclusives in ModernGUI. Which indeed makes champion cavalry or infantry represented in both columns.
That's not a bug, that's also like this in the autociv panel for example, and it make sens.
But it gave me the idea to try to make things clearer by adding an a little spacer between champs and the rest, as it's the only column that a unit can be represented twice.

Or you could probably count infantry classes which arent champ, same for cav

[AlexHerbert]

Is not about the gui, it is ok.

What is confusing is the fact that the guy is supposed 1100, he told me he is nub but he made 100 champs, plus he made wonder, the pop limit should have increased, and the stats show me numbers that don't make sense for me 

I just post this just in case the guy report me bc I quitted.

Edited 15 hours ago by AlexHerbert

[Atrik]

2 minutes ago, guerringuerrin said:

Or you could probably count infantry classes which arent champ, same for cav

Yes, you could. But if you lookup "Cav" column you expect to see how much Cavs there are for that player... Not just Cavs that aren't Champ. Well, might be more obvious to me who do use it.
The counters aren't trying to be breakdown of pop space used. Some units aren't represented at all; some units could cost multiple population space etc etc...

[Gurken Khan]

12 minutes ago, AlexHerbert said:

numbers that don't make sense for me

174 + 1 + 25 = 200

100 of those 174 inf are champions, 1 horse, 25 women.

[guerringuerrin]

18 minutes ago, Atrik said:

Yes, you could. But if you lookup "Cav" column you expect to see how much Cavs there are for that player... Not just Cavs that aren't Champ. Well, might be more obvious to me who do use it.
The counters aren't trying to be breakdown of pop space used. Some units aren't represented at all; some units could cost multiple population space etc etc...

yeah u r right. its unneccesary and just complicate things

[AlexHerbert]

Idk, take in count I am nub.

But Maybe would be good idea to show inf and cav champs in different columns.

Thank for your responses.

[AlexHerbert]

Maybe something like this mockup. Ofc with your design.

Just saying!

Edited 13 hours ago by AlexHerbert

[Deicide4u]

3 hours ago, Gurken Khan said:

200

100 of those 174 inf are champions, 1 horse, 25 women.

Very strong economy, 1500 elo player smurfing as 1100.

100%

[Seleucids]

4 hours ago, AlexHerbert said:

 

This is indeed less ambiguous. However, you would then have to specify the citizen class and the champion class, which occupies too much space and attention. Most of the time, I just want to know how many units I am fielding in a fight and how many of them are champion class. 

 

The autociv counter shows Kingsman has 174 infantry units and 100 of them are of the champion class. 

 

I have played with this Kingsman10 before, he is not a smurf, just a casual player. My question is: how did you allow him to mass up 100 champion swordsman? It is minute 25 and both you are floating huge amounts of resources with less than a dozen kills? If you invested those resources in your own champs and earlier attacks, he would be dead now. He probably ecobotted harder and deleted more of his women to free space. 

[AlexHerbert]

@Seleucids I am already in discord, thanks for the tips