-
Who's Online 5 Members, 1 Anonymous, 1159 Guests (See full list)
-
Topics
-
Posts
-
I am fully aware of this, and that is precisely the crux of my argument. Neither *þurpa nor *haimaz is directly attested in Proto-Germanic. Their forms and meanings are reconstructed from later evidence. Our earliest extensive Germanic evidence comes from fourth-century Gothic, where þaurp refers to agricultural land or a farm, while haims repeatedly means "village" or "hamlet". Beyond Gothic, we must therefore look for independent evidence that can help us reconstruct the earlier semantic history of both words. In the case of *haimaz, the collective meaning is independently supported by early Frankish evidence and some of the oldest Germanic place-name traditions in -heim, -hem and -hām. These names were used very early on to refer to communities and villages. The chronological evidence is particularly important. Stefan Brink assigns some Scandinavian -he(i)m names to the centuries around the beginning of the Common Era and dates Vattjom to approximately AD 200. German place-name research likewise treats -heim as one of the oldest settlement-name types, with possible sporadic formations around the beginning of the Common Era and increasing productivity during the Migration Period. This makes it highly plausible that the collective and territorial meaning of *haimaz was already present at an early Germanic stage. I'm not sure I see the relevance of that. The Celtic comparison may help reconstruct the wider history of the Indo-European root, but it cannot by itself determine the meaning of *haimaz in Proto-Germanic. Germanic and Celtic had been separate branches for a very long time (at least since 2500 BC), and cognates in separate branches can undergo substantial and independent semantic developments. The relevant question is therefore not whether a Celtic cognate developed a particular meaning, but which interpretation best explains the internal Germanic evidence. For that purpose, Gothic, Frankish, Old English and the early Germanic place-name traditions are more directly relevant than semantic developments within Celtic. I do not see how this contradicts my argument. Etymology suggests that these words derive from an Indo-European root that meant "to be lying down, to settle". In some cases, words derived from this root have come to refer to the concept of a dwelling, while in others, they have come to denote relationships through the notion of sleeping in the same place as other people. Brink’s examples show precisely that distinct derivatives of the same root could coexist with different meanings within the same language. The absence of a surviving Celtic settlement term from this particular formation therefore does not establish that Proto-Germanic *haimaz lacked such a meaning. More importantly, the meaning "village" did not appear solely in Gothic. It is independently represented in Old English and Frankish evidence, while the corresponding place-name tradition is ancient and geographically widespread. The most economical explanation is that the collective meaning was inherited from an earlier Germanic stage, rather than independently invented several times. You are isolating Brink’s final sentence from the argument that leads to it. When he defines the semantic core as "the area and place where you live", he is not restricting it to one individual’s private house. Immediately before that conclusion, he applies the same concept to farms, villages and inhabited territories. His final sentence summarizes that range, it does not erase the collective meanings established throughout the chapter. Once again, the collective application is not unique to Gothic. Old English hām and Old Saxon hēm clearly referred to villages in many cases and they were associated to the earliest period of settling, during the 5th and 6th centuries. The Frankish evidence also supports some collective applications of haima. The toponymic evidence independently points in the same direction. The cumulative evidence shows that its collective and territorial application is ancient, geographically widespread and independently represented in several Germanic traditions. According to whom? In the game, the Roman first-phase term is "Vicus", a similarly flexible word that could refer, depending on context, to a rural settlement, an urban quarter, a principal street, a local community or an estate-like establishment. It was not a fixed demographic category within a three-level hierarchy. The semantic flexibility of *haimaz is therefore not inherently a weakness. Just like the word "Vicus", "Haimaz" likely referred to villages, as is the case in Gothic, Old English, Old Saxon, and Frankish. I have not. The earliest Germanic evidence does not support *þurpa as the clearer collective settlement term. In Gothic, þaurp is not used for any of the numerous villages mentioned in the biblical text. Its sole surviving occurrence refers to agricultural land or a farm. By contrast, haims repeatedly denotes villages and participates in explicit contrasts between rural settlements and cities. Nor does the agricultural meaning of þaurp appear to be a uniquely Gothic innovation. Scholars interpret þorp in the Hávamál as heathland or upland meadow, while Old Scandinavian evidence preserves torp for individual farms and agricultural holdings. Medieval Swedish law similarly uses the term for a single, often small farm, possibly detached from a village. These meanings belong naturally to a semantic field centred on an agricultural establishment and its associated land. Villages could subsequently develop through the division of a large farm, the addition of dependent holdings or the clustering of several farms. The collective settlement meaning is therefore readily explained as a later semantic expansion without treating Gothic as an isolated exception. The chronology of the place-name evidence is consistent with this semantic development. Names in -heim are generally assigned to some of the oldest layers of Germanic settlement nomenclature. Some Scandinavian examples may date from around the beginning of the Common Era, and the continental type became increasingly productive during the Migration Period. By contrast, widespread formations in -þorp, -torp and -dorf are characteristically associated with later phases of settlement expansion, agricultural colonisation and rural reorganisation like the spread of the manorial system (Grundherrschaft / Fronhof). I have already shared Stefan Brink’s explanation: "The medieval element torp, however, must be seen in a context of the huge colonisation in northern Europe during the high Middle Ages, within a new ‘feudal’ agrarian system with a ‘manor’ and dependent tenant farms within an estate. In Germany these tenant farms often had the name dorf (< þorp), and the word for such a dependent farm was spread with the new colonising strategy to Scandinavia. Early on, the element torp must have developed into a meaning of secondary farm, a farm detached from a hamlet etc., hence not always denoting a tenant farm within an estate." I'll add the conclusion by Richard Jones, David N. Parsons, and Paul Cullen from their book (Thorps in a Changing Landscape): "We must also recognise ultimately that we are dealing with a group of places that began to form in the ninth and tenth centuries, and would continue to do so well into the early modern period. We are dealing, then, with a place-name that has currency for over a millennium. There is every likelihood that, over this time, the original sense of the term or its defining features will have been lost, forgotten or become irrelevant. Certainly, by the end of the Middle Ages we already seem to pick up a transformation from something specific to something more general. For Langland and Chaucer, writing in the fourteenth century, a thorp had become a byword for any small rural settlement. No small wonder, then, that when the full corpus is examined, some of the relationships we have uncovered – in particular, the link between soil types and these places – becomes weaker. Over time, the sense that thorps were places specifically engaged in arable farming appears to be lost. [...] That said, we believe that the history of many thorps, perhaps the greater majority of them, may well be closely entwined with the story of the open fields of England. These small, dependent and seemingly unimportant – some might say irrelevant – places, we suggest, played a pivotal role in the cereal revolution of the early medieval period and the consequent reorganisation of the English landscape in the two centuries either side of the Norman Conquest. Thorps were born out of these transformations of farming practices and settlement patterns from the late ninth century onwards." It is entirely consistent with a development in which *þurpa- first referred to a newly established agricultural holding and later became productive for secondary farms, hamlets and villages. The later -torp and -dorf place names therefore document what the word meant during particular phases of colonisation and agricultural reorganisation. They cannot simply be projected backwards as transparent evidence for its Proto-Germanic meaning. The claim that Gothic uniquely innovated is consequently difficult to sustain. Gothic is not the only Germanic tradition preserving agricultural or non-village meanings. Comparable meanings occur in Old Norse poetry, Scandinavian legal terminology and later dialectal usage. Gothic therefore appears less as an isolated exception than as an early witness to a broader semantic range centred on an agricultural establishment and its land. By contrast, the collective use of cognates of *haimaz is directly attested, ancient and geographically widespread, while its toponymic descendants belong to some of the earliest settlement-naming traditions of the Germanic world. For these reasons, I still consider Haimaz the stronger and historically better-supported choice for the game’s initial settlement phase.
-
By Nicolaus_von_Kues · Posted
I said a while ago that we needed an element that would automatically patch the game or at least allow the player to test the new balances without depending on a mod. Now I think I should have a fast ring and a slow one. https://windowsreport.com/windows-insider-rings/ -
By guerringuerrin · Posted
I'm not part of the balance team. I just contribute wherever I can. And honestly, I'm not sure whether I'm capable of delivering good results. In my opinion, there are a few other changes that could be made, such as slightly nerfing slingers and improving archers. That said, I think finding the right balance is difficult, and implementing too many changes at once could be a disaster. Especially considering that updates throughout the year are almost nonexistent, a major rebalance could leave us with a very negative gameplay experience for an entire year. My understanding is that the idea behind the Community Mod was to bring some dynamism to the game through regular updates, allowing for balance fine-tuning and testing of features that could potentially be incorporated into the main game. Unfortunately, the people involved and the time available seem to be very limited. This year, the Community Mod was barely tested. Very few people contributed to testing it. I've done what I could to promote the mod, but ever since I moved, I haven't been hosting games anymore because my connection has been unstable. And the most popular hosts at the moment haven't committed to supporting this initiative. So much so that they haven't even voted in the poll. I don't think they even visit the forums much. I've left messages on the Discord servers where I've seen them active, but it didn't lead to anything. -
@real_tabasco_sauce @guerringuerrin @Atrik don't you think the game could use a lot more balance changes than just focusing on naked fanas and champ cav for an update of the whole year? hints at sussy reforms
-
