Jump to content

av_nefardec

WFG Retired
  • Posts

    4.772
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by av_nefardec

  1. Ok, I'm going to create the reading group subforums within the book forums to which they pertain in the GD.

    I think there is enough interest to go ahead with this, but we certainly would like more. Particularly, I would like to get involved those who have read the books fewer times than us :P (and especially Shawn)

    Also, do you think it is a good idea to have discussion leaders? By that I mean one person who knows a good amount about the books already who can sort of jumpstart discussion if it gets stagnant. Maybe this person also gives a short description of what to observe or look for in each reading.

    A key thing will be for everyone to be as inquisitive and open about questions and curiousities as possible.

    And finally, as Matteo suggested, we should use this to build up the Ardaquenta. There's no better time to write an article or make an addition to an article (or a correction) than immediately after you've read it in the text.

  2. No that's Saria's Song, which is one of the songs from The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time, but not the theme. It's the one played in the Lost Forest or whatever it's called. En route to the Forest Temple.

    It's going to be a strange film.

  3. Yeah I don't know so much that it would be harder to balance - in fact it might make it more balanced in some random cases.

    The main problem is whether or not it accurately reflects training.

    Also there is the gameplay problem. One major problem that players have with random map games for example is "getting map-screwed", which means that where they start off in a map has a low amount of potential for growth, etc.

    It would be quite unfortunate to get both map-screwed and unit-stat-screwed ;)

  4. Nice tidbit: the title of The Lord of the Rings isn't translated literally, which would've been 'De Heer van de Ringen', but was made 'In de ban van de Ring', which

    That's really odd, considering German is "Der Herr der Ringe" (though that is a singular form of what translates to "ring" which is different" - since the "der" preceding "ringe" is a singular feminine genitive article) and Spanish is El Señor del los Anillos, which is pretty much a direct translation.

    I recall Tolkien having some quarrels with a Dutchman in his letters as to translations of things - I'll have to look at that again.

  5. I'm not sure if the "chant" by Arwen was appropriate.

    Gandalf explains that Loudwater is under the "command" of Elrond.

    Elrond is both King and Master of that land, so it makes good sense.

    Arwen however has nothing except for relation to Elrond.

    Also I guess I just like the way the book was written, which really made the reader see how miraculous indeed the flood would have seemed to Frodo/Glorfindel. Only later, in Book II does the reader learn that it was "commanded" by Elrond.

    I guess I might have exaggerated my idea of river enchantment, because the river being under command could translate to several things. We like to think "enchantment", but I suppose that could easily mean he has it dammed up and can release a torrent down the valley.

    Maybe if Arwen's chant had a plea to Ossë it would have made me more happy ;) But otherwise it sounds like Arwen can summon it magically or something, instead of either having control over it as a master or praying for aid.

  6. What's surregionalist poety, btw?

    Basically, there is a group of Modern Surrealists called "Le Corpse Exquis" (The Exquisite Corpse, their name stems from an old parlour game)

    http://www.corpse.org

    These surrealists call themselves "Surregionalists", and it's a play on words -

    Surrealism + Regionalism.

    Surregionalism is sort of like a nonconformist movement away from a centralised mainstream.

  7. Elysium

    How I long to be a warrior-king of old

    Doer of deeds undying

    Forever idolized in immortal stone

    My likeness preserved in the very earth I rule

    My name whispered yet by the winds aloft

    My achievements quenching every desire of this barren life like a desert rain

    My memory igniting the burning passions of another age

    How I long to hear my name whispered among the ages

    Echoing from eon to eon in the vastness of eternity

    Undying, unyielding as the stone in which it is graven

    What sweet solace for a destitute mortality

    How I long to fall in battle or on errantry

    To have my people bear my body upon a bier

    To meld with the earth in a snow-crowned barrow

    To burn into corporal oblivion upon a high pyre

    As the winds scatter my ashes to the ends of the world

    To have my body sent out over the wide, dark seas

    A final journey forth into the uttermost west

    Where I may find peace among heroes in Elysium.

  8. Eek, looks like you're using snowblades! ;)

    I'm strictly a downhill skier - no snowboards, cross country skis.

    I used to be a pretty good skier since I took lessons for several years when I was younger. Unfortunately I stopped for some reason and now my skis and boots no longer fit me.

    I live so close to so many resorts in NY now too, but I have no time to go :P

    I have fond memories of skiing into the snowboard terrain park right next to the snowboarders with my friends and doing the jumps and pipes. Some of the best terrain was always on the edge of the resort, with natural drop-offs and jumps that were quite high.

    And skiing down slopes that were so steep as you weave down them you can touch them with your hand ;)

    *envies the europeans who can go to the alps*

  9. So what are the (technical) differences between a round and a 'iron-shaped' shield? Does it matter what kind of shield I would have as a soldier?

    Matteo (rohirwine) would know the best answers to this since this is what he studies and what he does for TLA.

    From my limited knowledge, I think the reason in history the "Kite" Shield evolved was because it was used by Mounted Knights, and it had to be elongated to cover their shield side from attack. Then they began to put heraldic devices on their shields and the design stuck.

    In Middle-earth, it's possible that the same development occured. Tolkien was certainly in love with Heraldry.

  10. The Gondolindrim were a those Noldor of the House of Fingolfin originally from Vinyamar led by Turgon to Gondolin, and those who escaped its fall and remained refugees.

    As the son of Fingolfin, Turgon was part of the mainstream Noldorin leadership and his people were part of the Mainstream Noldorin culture.

    The Gondolindrim, like the Noldor of Nargothrond, like the Noldor of Nevrast, like any group of Noldor identified only by their place of residence yet united by their culture, will be part of the First Age Noldorin Civilization in TLA.

    In the game, a player can choose a leader for his civilization, which further defines that civ.

    For instance the FA Noldor have the following leaders:

    Fingolfin

    Fingon

    Turgon

    If a player wishes his Noldorin civilization to be more like the Gondolindrim than perhaps another Noldorin contigent, then he can choose Turgon as a leader, and he will grant specific bonuses and penalties relevant to the Gondolindrim.

    In a scenario, the designer can customize the civilization and what not to make this even more established.

    Major Civilizations in TLA usually contain more than one "subculture" of any major culture. The Second and Third Age Noldor, for instance, encompasses the Mithlondrim, as well as those Noldor of Imladris, Elostirion, etc

  11. (that I imagined to be iron-shaped (like in to iron your clothes))

    Such a shield might make it difficult for a Noldorin Swordsman to fight - but expect to see a Noldorin Spearman - the Sentinel, wielding such a shield as you describe.

×
×
  • Create New...