Jump to content

Thalatta

Community Members
  • Posts

    677
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    16

Thalatta last won the day on October 14

Thalatta had the most liked content!

2 Followers

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Thalatta's Achievements

Primus Pilus

Primus Pilus (7/14)

385

Reputation

  1. The discussion was never about its latter attested haimaz cognates not meaning some kind of settlement (are you getting confused with the þurpa discussion?), but if that was the case in Proto-Germanic times. That's why I agree with the quotes you bring up, but they are completely irrelevant to the point in question. By "early" and "late" I obviously meant in reference to the Germanic-Celtic split, bringing up the "late medieval" period is quite the misrepresentation. Your source (Brink) does address what you keep ignoring regarding Celtic by saying "in Old Celtic languages we find a related formation that demonstrates another interesting theme, namely the meaning 'love'", and as you quote, concludes his chapter with: This is exactly my point (yet again you are brushing off the actual conclusions of your own sources). He refers to one's home (one's "area and place"), this doesn't necessarily point to a type of settlement, and at no point he claims that in Proto-Germanic times it referred to anything outside one's own (as seems to happen in Gothic and later, but it's completely different in Proto-Celtic and later). I completely agree, since this is my exact argument regarding þurpa. I'm glad you brought up this point, since it's the one I was going to follow up with. Two characteristics are important to name a Phase: its "multiple dwelling" quality, and its development stage. Regarding Proto-Germanic haimaz, your source doesn't claim anything beyond that it referred to one's home, even if that could have indirectly referred (only to) one's own settlement, and we both agree it can be of any size. Regarding Proto-Germanic þurpa, I've already proven its "multiple dwelling" quality using your own sources, and we both agree that it's small. Simply put: no. Urban development is the actual point of Phase names, and you know it, that's why you are pre-emptively trying to dismiss this obvious conclusion supporting what I say (as you've tried to do before). You have reached, in good part by yourself, the conclusion that þurpa is more appropriate than haimaz for Phase I, according to each of both important characteristics mentioned (being multiple dwellings, but a few).
  2. There's the discussion regarding þurpą reconstruction, and there's the later discussion regarding the attested cognates. Regarding the latter, you have been trying to argue that one can see the earliest attested cognates refer to a farmstead, or according to you, a single dwelling, first with OHG, but then I've shown that OE is attested earlier. Concerning that latest discussion, "original meaning" can only refer to the time of the EE glossary. Then, although "the study is mainly concerned with the period from around 850 to 1250", it's not correct to say that "they are not claiming that the word thorp had always denoted such a cluster, nor that several buildings were necessarily part of its original meaning", since I've shown they do claim this when they stated that compitum in the EE must have also been interpreted as a "small rural settlement" (conclusion I arrived at independently, in part considering they would emerge right there) by "unsophisticated people". But you know this, since later you dismiss this evidence by saying that It's not reasonable to suppose that more exploration would have led to the conclusion that "thorp" was actually a single dwelling at the time of the EE glossary, which was your claim. That would be basically the opposite of what they are already claiming, which aligns with the current EE translation (published a few years later), as I've already explained. But maybe focusing on þurpą in what follows will clarify this even further. Concerning þurpą reconstruction (the other interpretation of "original meaning"), my claim is not exactly that "Proto-Germanic þurpą already referred to a village or hamlet", that's semantically charged, but that þurpą probably didn't restrict itself to a single farmstead. Then I guess you could call this collection of farmsteads a settlement, a hamlet, or small village, but none of that is my original claim (just approximate terms to emphasise a contraposition with your single dwelling claim). My claim is based on that (new relevant information is added in the last point): -The Germanic cognates you tried to use to further your claim actually support mine, as demonstrated from your sources. The rare unique instance in Gothic cannot be reliably used, and could have treated a collection of farmsteads as "farmland", like Ekwall seems to do. -The Celtic cognates also refer to a settlement larger than a single farmstead, further reinforcing the view that, if that was the actual meaning in Gothic, it was indeed the exception. This is way more parsimonious than thinking that the "earliest meaning was closer to the one preserved in Gothic" and everything else changed. -The Proto-Germanic reconstruction is often associated with "crowd" and "settlement". While you pointed out that the latter is ambiguous, Kroonen's student states, when questioning if Latin trabs is also a cognate, that "while all the other comparanda refer to dwellings, settlements, and communities, Lat. trabs sometimes refers to part of a building". Through his thesis he consistently uses the word "settlement" to describe multiple dwellings, and small "communities" is exactly what I've been talking about (conclusion I arrived at independently, in part considering the association with "crowd"). Notice how, even when listing in the previous page that in Gothic it meant "farmland", absolutely nothing is said about that for Proto-Germanic. Regarding the quotes from the book towards the end, I know them, they either align with my claim or don't go against it, and certainly don't support a single dwelling interpretation. Many specific characteristics regarding thorps is why I said to bear in mind they "don't necessarily apply to þurpą, being a cognate many centuries after the fact". The relevant claims in question are the ones I just restated in this post.
  3. @Genava55 your first post is clear and I agree with most of it, except what you seem to actually stand for, which seems confirmed in your second post. Yes, "settlement" can be ambiguous, but many times it's clear what's being said from context, or even explicitly explained. When that book says "small settlements", it's clear that they refer to a few dwellings and not to the size of a single one. You argue against thorps usually "being more than a single farmstead" by referring to my quote as an "isolated example", but use a couple of isolated examples to say there's no "sufficient basis for attributing to the authors a conclusion they do not themselves formulate", when they actually conclude: Which has been my point all along. I wouldn't say an "unambiguous synonym for 'village'" is intended to be attached by current sources. As I've said many times, this association doesn't have to refer to a full-blown village, that might well be an exaggeration, it's just a matter of resemblance. When "hamlet or village" is used, what is meant is that there are multiple dwellings (or farmsteads, if you will), and not just a single one, and after all, all this kind of started when you said: Even when that might be an exaggeration and "hamlet is a very few dwellings" should be put in-between. The central issue is clear and I've mentioned it many times: are we dealing with a single farmstead or a group of them? I think it's clear most of the current evidence points to the group, and why it's no big issue that the current EE translation uses "hamlet or village", not in the spirit of saying thorps were proper villages, but that they were "small settlements" made up from a "collection of dwellings". Maybe Ekwall (who, again, died over 60 years ago) wanted to call all that just "farm", possibly "hamlet", but not "village", but taking that old sentence literally is misleading, considering what the current evidence tries to imply. And still, all that is only half of the argument. You still have not commented on Celtic cognates of haimaz having no relation with any kind of settlement, while þurpą cognates are consistently more settlement-like, showing it's doubtful to think haimaz mainly referred to some kind of settlement early on, while þurpą likely did. I still think you got too focused on Gothic and later (we are still talking about OE thorps after all) instead of the bigger picture provided by both branches and explaining why the accepted reconstructions are what they are.
  4. Thanks for answering like a reasonable person. I agree with what you say regarding sources. I just think you are challenging the current sources by using older ones that are actually being criticised by the former in the first place (Oliphant and Ekwall published over 60 years ago, let alone other sources you have quoted). You have to recognise that as circular reasoning. I'll try to demonstrate this as explicitly as possible, while trying to answer what you ask. You wanted to shut down the "hamlet or village" meaning and imply circular reasoning from the current EE experts with your statement characterising the "village" entry as "completely illogical". You also said "tuun at this time still meant enclosure", and (using the "Compitum = Tūn = Throp" equivalence), "throp in the Épinal-Erfurt is obviously not of village". This line of reasoning is unsubstantiated, since the "village" meaning appeared early during Saxon colonisation, before the EE. You hopefully now agree with that, given that you said "this reflects both the semantic shift toward the meanings of "homestead" and "village", which, according to Ekwall, emerged early on without distinguishing between the two". Still, this only proves that the 2016 (reviewed in 2022/2023) "village or hamlet" translation is possible, not that it's correct yet. How to get closer to that? Let's look at the current evidence, particularly if it analyses the older evidence. I'm going to use another of your sources: Thorps in a Changing Landscape, from Richard Jones, David N. Parsons and Paul Cullen, from 2011, containing the extremely relevant "Appendix 1: Throp in Anglo-Saxon glosses", which you used to heavily recline on compitum to justify thorp just being a "gathering place". You quoted: and then you said: Which I don't find convincing given the current evidence. So I went to your source, and found that then it says: and: and then mentions the "plausible guess" that all could have come from "qui alieni a ciuitate Dei ex locorum agrestium conpitis et pagis pagani uocantur", that is, "those who, alienated from the kingdom of God, are called ‘pagans’, from the conpitis and pagis of rural places", concluding that: And you saw but omitted all that, because that's followed by the sentences you quoted from Isidore of Seville regarding what a compitum is, and then even said: when actually that source, just after the Isidore of Seville statements, adds: And the source continues a bit regarding these things, stating that glosses And that chapter ends in that page, not changing the conclusion that both throp with tūn refer to "small agrarian settlements", and compitum is not a "straightforward translation", but probably "misunderstood, or partially understood, as referring to small rural settlements" by "unsophisticated people" (to which I independently hinted before with another source you didn't find convincing, even after you had read that). This is why I say you can't just give more weight to older entries lacking in analysis than to current relevant discussions directly criticising them. And please notice that your quoting highly misrepresents what's being said: you end up concluding the opposite of what's actually said. I could go on ranting about this, but I'll refrain because you were respectful in your previous answer. They clearly explained what you quoted in order to promptly criticise it. I leave "hidden" screenshots of this nice 6-page long appendix for anyone to read it: There are many other things worth checking from that source about thorps which directly imply them being more than a single farmstead, for example this quote explicitly stating that that would just be the case for quite derelict ones: One has to bear in mind that certain thorp characteristics don't necessarily apply to þurpą, being a cognate many centuries after the fact. All this focuses only on supporting the EE translation being a small settlement. I think it's then clear that there's no problem with the current evidence taking throp and tūn as a settlement larger than a single farmstead. This association can be tracked all the way back to þurpą, more recently shown in Kroonen's PhD student use of "settlement" (its association with "crowd" can also be found in other languages, that source mentions it for OHG, and it happens in Spanish with "pueblo", of course independently), and clearly present in the Celtic branch through PIE treb, a canonical example of Grimm's Law, as I've shown. In summary (and if you think I'm misrepresenting something, briefly point it out), because again, all has to be seen at the same time to make the actual point: Þurpa: at least the meanings crowd, settlement and hamlet are justified (by your own sources). While (full-blown) village might be an exaggeration, it is irrelevant for Phase I, as is the additional farmstead meaning, considering the nature of these settlements, and how Romans saw them. Gothic cannot be reliably used for this word in particular since there's only one attestation. You tried to argue that the settlement meaning only came much later in Old High German and Old Norse, but earlier Old English attestations prove that this cannot be the case, fact reinforced by the many languages presented in the Celtic branch, both reconstructed and attested, from where a size estimation of this larger than a farmstead settlement was also obtained. Even when for a few Celtic languages þurpą cognates are less settlement-like, they are still more so than their corresponding haimaz cognates, an extremely important point. All this shows that þurpą early on meaning only a single farmstead seems unlikely. Its meaning refers more often to a small settlement. Haimaz: at least the meanings home, homely and homestead are justified (by your own sources). Gothic has a stronger case here, although it translates haimaz cognates as country at least once, inverts wīhsą cognates urbanistic order, and all this is centuries after the fact. You tried to argue for it meaning settlement using Old High German, but this is ten centuries after the fact. Haimaz cognates ended up meaning settlement as in "someone's home", but this was not its original meaning, not only because the homely meaning is ever present and ambiguating in the Germanic branch, but because it's astoundingly dominant in the Celtic branch, showing that by the time PIE split into these two branches there was probably no settlement meaning yet, and the lack of any horizontal transfer hints to a rather late than early development, but it cannot be said at which point between Proto-Germanic and Gothic this meaning appeared. All this shows that haimaz early on meaning mainly settlement seems unlikely. Its meaning refers more often to a home. In conclusion, I do think þurpą is a better candidate than haimaz for a Phase I Proto-Germanic settlement, and that the accepted reconstructions are properly backed up by the latest evidence, which contains plenty of thoughtful criticism of the older evidence, as shown.
  5. I wasn't satisfied having just said "regarding something in particular": I mentioned Kroonen before because he gives þurpa meaning as "crowd", "which anyway blatantly contradicts your “singular first” interpretation". Then I ended up finding quite some interesting stuff: In the 2023 dissertation "Unde vēnistī? The Prehistory of Italic through its Loanword Lexicon", by A. M. Wigman, one of Kroonen's PhD students, one can find: It doesn't seem Kroonen disagreed much with his own student for that to end in the PhD thesis… not that we didn't know what "crowd" seemed to support already. Later on, it's stated that: And the relevant row compares Proto-Germanic *þurpa- with Proto-Celtic *treb- (a footnote states that "a note of caution is that it cannot be ruled out that reconstructions involving the operation of Verner’s Law might be misinterpretations", showing that, although a possibility, this is not a mainstream view, unlike what's in the main text). Finally, it's stated that many things there come "as no surprise if Grimm's Law operated in the mid-first millennium BCE", which shows this is already considered, and bears no major problem towards the reconstructions provided, making evident that this is not an issue: Here, why are you only considering one change? There are more as part of Grimm's Law, as From Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic, by D. Ringe, states: "by the second change subsumed under Grimm's Law PIE voiced stops became PGmc voiceless stops". This turns *b into *p, as expected, and the third example in that very same page is in fact: Which also includes village as one of the meanings of *þurpą.
  6. I'm not reading the forum anymore (only answering PMs because I'm still helping a couple of people, for a time at least), but saw your notification and the baffling misrepresentations, although a reply should not even be needed since anyone paying marginal attention would easily realise most of these things: Yet what you did is just to shove those sources when you didn't even properly read them. Calling showing you their actual contents "appeal to authority" or "mindlessly parroting" is not going to fool anyone, so you might want to change this old defensive trope, it got a bit repetitive and boring already. Just start by reading your own sources properly, in light of what the point of the discussion actually is, and maybe that will be a bit more productive. It's me who's astounded at your bad faith (or lack of understanding), because clearly at no point I implied that "all the definitions existed at the same time from the very beginning of the language", that's a hilariously nonsensical thing to say, and you should know it perfectly well, so the only one showing "always" "bad faith" here is you, considering also your constant infantile insults that only serve to talk about your own character. Anyway, furthermore: As always, the only dishonesty (or lack of understanding) comes from your part. The whole sentence is perfectly fine, and still implies that the meaning of village must have arisen at an early date, which I focused on just to show how wrong you were when stating that: Honestly, you need to find some integrity at some point and just be able to say "you know what, I was wrong with that", instead of throwing false accusations and keeping muddying the waters because your baseless arrogance doesn't allow you to recognise when it's resoundingly obvious that you've been completely cornered. Not being "commonest" doesn't mean absent. Still, hardly every point will be 100% convincing, and that one might well be the weakest one, but it's just a small part of the whole point you already seemed to agree to: that tuun also meant village or hamlet, and so did þrop (at least with hamlet, but as I said, that's more than enough for the point in question: that's more than a single homestead or farmstead). It's you who keeps "dodging the arguments that contradict you", even when using references first put forward by you. The real question here is, why would anyone give more weight to entries from decades old general purpose dictionaries instead of very recent specific studies on the actual matter? I have no doubt that if you keep digging you will find instances where þrop is translated as something closer to farmstead, what do you want me to say? Congratulations, do you want cookies? That dictionary doesn't even explain itself further. On the other hand, you keep dodging why the recent important EE reference and the other more explanatory dictionary, both put forward by you in the first place, align with what I say, and keep labelling all this "appeal to authority" or "mindlessly parroting", which just shows how helplessly out of cards you are. I think my previous post explained that quite extensively. You are assuming they (Gothic and OHG) "retained" the meaning, while other Germanic languages, along with the Celtic branch, changed. That's really not convincing, and why the actual reconstructions state what they state. So, it's not thoughtless at all to state that þurpą is associated with settlements, there are strong reasons for it, not only from the previous OE discussion, but also in my two paragraphs regarding this for reconstructed and attested Celtic languages, where in the last one I even managed to get a quantitative estimation of size, quite relevant for the point in question (although late, but please, give a try at something like that for an earlier period). And EVEN if we wanted to assume there was an "isolated farm buildings" meaning since the beginning, you keep circling around this already very extensively explained point: how could you possibly extricate farms from early Germanic settlements? Call them small villages, hamlets, collections of farmsteads, or whatever. The villages you showed before would be Phase III. We are discussing the less built up Phase I. This point is extremely important. I also already clearly explained why Gothic is such a bad reference, and months ago I stated that "it is not true that the "oldest writings in Germanic languages" (as if that goes beyond Gothic) support your point", as shown for OE. Besides, you keep dancing around the actual point and completely ignored the paragraph regarding Celtic cognates of haimaz having no relation with a settlement, but with what's homely, my original argument all along. Both words must be considered at the same time. And I did say "treb, is reconstructed as "settlement" (often just "dwelling")". You are the one dismissing the debate, you are the one accusing me of all sorts of idiotic things for presenting the mainstream view. You keep coming with alternative views intending to disregard the rest, but why would I give more weight to these dissenting voices? They exist, and I've been quite honest about that, months ago I said "the only outlying source I find is Kroonen" (regarding something in particular), so it's hysterical that you say I'm the one keeping dodging what contradicts me, given that, your attitude towards the content I "parrot" from your own sources, your accusations when I explicitly proved you wrong regarding the tuun meaning, your dodging of the Celtic cognates of haimaz, and many other things. All your accusations against me fly back right at you in the most blatant manner. It's clear where the consensus is given the accepted reconstructions (and all I've shown that aligns with that), and you might as well go and write the EE experts you quoted in the first place, but that end contradicting you, how awfully wrong they are (too bad you didn't even bother searching through their whole thing, which I did, and luckily found the relevant entry early on, under C), but in the meantime there's really not much you can do about any of it, which makes your whole insulting remarks and misrepresentations even more disgusting and unacceptable (too sad that, from what I've seen lately in the forum, you do have company though).
  7. I'm deleting my contribution notes but I think this one I wrote down in May is worth leaving here since it addresses some clear issues with the previous answers (although the point has already been made, but even more clearly here). I just didn't care to post it, still really don't, but it has some interesting information (even when the mentality of not giving much worth to these type of contributions has been recently demonstrated): Are you even aware that my screenshot is from your own reference Towards a New Edition of the Épinal-Erfurt Glossary, by Michael W. Herren and Hans Sauer, from 2016? Why wasn't it an "appeal to authority" when you used it? Or when you quote anything at all? That's not "completely illogical", but just how language works. The word tuun did designate village because they could be an 'enclosure', after all Kluge "mentions OE betȳnan (a derivative of tūn), "to enclose, hedge in", before quoting this highly significant sentence found in the ASC (about the foundation of Bamborough in 547): "sēō wæs ǣrost mid hecge betȳned and þǣr æfter mid wealle" ("it/which was first enclosed by a hedge and then by a wall"). In his OE dictionary, Borden gives us an exhaustive list of all the meanings of tūn (within a semantic continuum between what is smallest and what is largest at both ends): "enclosed place; dwelling, enclosure, garden, field, yard, farm, manor; homestead, house, mansion; group of houses, village, town"", while the meaning of "'village' must have arisen at an early date as shown among other things by the numerous names in -tūn, even -ingatum found in Normandy and the Boulogne district and apparently due to early Saxon colonization in the district. Saxons are mentioned here by Gregory of Tours in the 6th century", when already "in the Vth century, Saxons became "permanent settlers" in northern and western Gaul" (https://www.persee.fr/doc/bamed_0240-8805_2017_num_90_1_1160), and all this is so well documented (even you couldn't avoid quoting a translation contradicting your own position) "that I don't understand how you can't see it". In addition, although in Classical Latin conpetum/conpitum means "cross-roads", by the time of the EE glossary settlements would have developed at many of these junctions (https://www1.leiza.de/transformation/posterexposition/transformationposter08uk.pdf), and this really doesn't have much to do with just a single farm. That's why the combination of tuun and conpetum, used to describe þrop, is translated as "village or hamlet" by the people specifically studying the EE glossary, who were cited by you in the first place. Besides, the letter C, under which this translation is placed, was extensively reviewed between 2022 and 2023, if not also more recently (https://epinal-erfurt.artsci.utoronto.ca/index.php/corrections). None of this changes because of particular and/or outdated quotes that have been of course considered in the bigger picture already. As mentioned, you already cited a current relevant reference specifically focused on what those early OE glosses say. When shown its actual translations in my screenshot, you disavowed it, accused me of "appeal to authority", and now found instead, first, some 2009 random reference dealing with another subject, and then another from an author who died over 60 years ago. This cherry-picking leads nowhere. But sure, let's use that old Oxford dictionary, let's compare the haimaz and þurpą OE cognates, that is, ham and thorp, using your new (older) reference: "ham from the first meant 'home, homestead'" (which you completely ignored), while for þrop "its meaning is doubtful", and was used "possibly in the sense of hamlet" (and similar things you quoted), which is what I've been saying all along, and the actual point of the discussion you are just dancing around: originally haimaz was ambiguous and more related to home or house, while þurpą was some kind of larger, whatever small, settlement. It doesn't need to refer to a full-blown "village" to be the better option for Phase 1 (and you are just returning yet again to the point of where you would put the line between a hamlet and a village at that time anyway, which is not even necessary). All that should be way more than enough, but let's take it further and do what I've been mentioning all along regarding other languages: look at the Celtic branch, for instance. According to the Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic, by Ranko Matasović, and taking a step back, the PIE cognate of þurpą, treb, is reconstructed as "settlement" (often just "dwelling"). Moving forwards, Proto-Celtic trebā is reconstructed as "settlement", as is Proto-Brythonic treβ. Are those also wrong, according to you? Let's look at immediate descendants for which there are actual texts (of course, you should cross-check everything): For Old Welsh, a very early attestation of the cognate treb can be found in margin entries of the 8th century Lichfield Gospels (the Old Welsh text added at most in the 9th century, according to the Geiriadur Prifysgol Cymru). It says "Osdendit ista scriptio quod dederunt ris et luith grethi treb guidauc", which in the Palaeographia Sacra Pictoria, by J. O. Westwood, is rendered into Latin and modern Welsh as "Ostendit ista scriptio quod dederunt Rhesus et familia Gretlii Trev wydhog… (nomen loci)", where this Trev wydhog (Trefwyddog) is clearly big enough to be a named place. There are plenty of sources addressing this: Studies in Celtic History, edited by Broun, Ní Mhaonaigh and Pryce, states "'Lanecros' was a grange of Talley Abbey, occupying the eastern part of the parish between the rivers Camddwr and Twrch. Originally this had been a much larger estate, Trefwyddog, recorded as a marginal grant of mid-ninth-century date to Llandeilo in the Lichfield Gospel", clearly making a tref "much larger" than a grange, that is, a farm estate. The Agrarian History of England and Wales, by Joan Thirsk, discusses the previous case and defines multiple times the term tref as a township. In the Aberystwyth Studies, by Members of the University College of Wales, the 10th century codification of the Laws by Hywel Dda are mentioned, which define "the homestead, tyddyn, was somewhat less than four acres in extent. A tref consisted of 256 acres", showing how "much larger" a tref is compared to a homestead. I also checked for Old Breton, but it's hard to get a grasp on sizes, although in A Dictionary of Old Breton, by C. Evans and L. Fleuriot, the derivative "trebou" is given as a "division of a parish", and this is not just someone's farmstead, given one can refer to "elements within the parish, such as a particular settlement and its fields", as The Oxford Handbook of Later Medieval Archaeology in Britain, by C.M. Gerrard and A. Gutiérrez, states. On the other hand, and using the same sources, the PIE cognate of haimaz, ḱóymos, is reconstructed as "of the home, belonging to the family". Moving forwards, Proto-Celtic koymo is reconstructed as "dear, nice", as is Proto-Brythonic kʉβ̃. For Welsh cu is translated preferably as "dear, beloved, amiable, pleasant", and for Old Breton cum is translated as "sweet, dear". I'm not going to go through more immediate descendants like with the þurpą cognates because the point should be beyond clear by now. The point is: already with PIE cognates, þurpą seems to relate to a settlement (whatever small, more than enough to describe Phase I), and haimaz to something much more ambiguous, related to what's homely (not as appropriate to describe Phase I). In other languages where the cognate of þurpą is closer to a farm, the cognate of haimaz is still closer to what I've mentioned (for example in Old Irish). The only one I've come across seemingly inverting this relation is, you guessed it, Gothic, with haims meaning village (sometimes country anyway) and þaurp meaning farm (in only one instance anyway). There could be a few others, but considering what has just been said, the evidence you have tried to put forward is incomplete, circumstantial and unrepresentative, that is, Gothic closeness to PGmc is no guarantee of anything without the proper comparative studies. What is your explanation for all that has been mentioned? That both developments happened independently in the Germanic and Celtic languages? That there was a massive horizontal transfer? That the current PIE (and their descendants) reconstructions are somehow wrong? All with what evidence? Those who reconstructed all these languages back to PIE agree that the meanings I state were present at least back then (which is why I mentioned PIE in the first place long ago without explaining much, to which you remarked "I don't see any relevance in this line of argument", hopefully now it's clearer). I left this one for last just to make more evident how absurdly it comes across, more so considering that you tried to wield the EE glossary while ignoring not only that it's included in the Corpus (one of the first things to know about it), but that its contents state what I say (as per my screenshot from your own specific reference). I even used the dictionary you tried to run to after that to expose both definitions (of ham and thorp), and then compared with the Celtic branch (not even needed, but it seems you are a bit stuck "repeating the same appeal to authority over and over"). So, don't fall into the apparent local tradition of denigrating people when you disagree with something, it doesn't further your argument, quite the contrary. In conclusion, it's not correct to assume that þurpą (cognates) only meant at most a single farmstead at that stage, and less so that the meaning only changed to some kind of small settlement much later in the Germanic branch (with OHG), unconvincingly implying that it also happened independently in the Celtic branch. Its "crowd" etymology has been discussed already, and reinforces all this. The stated ambiguity of haimaz (cognates) is also constantly reinforced. It is then quite clear then why the accepted PGmc reconstructions say what they say, and why there are no sufficient arguments for any revisionism. Anyway, that was mildly fun. I'm not reading the forum any more so I leave it to someone more impartial that might be able to deal with the matter, like @Ultimate Aurelian.
  8. @real_tabasco_sauce I'd like to remind you something you said in the illuminating thread I referenced: I agree with that, that's why I'm even against increasing training times and "every phase up would reduce training times" mentioned there, that would make the start of the game too slow for competitive players. I proposed instead (apparently ironically amazingly) increasing training times but making batching more efficient to keep the current training times for more average sized batches (again, all balance-pending, since this might make comebacks too strong, larger batches being produced even faster than currently). Lower difficulty AIs should not batch. I also find interesting the idea mentioned there that Mercenaries "should be able to be recruited very quickly", which could apply to their batch efficiency, giving them an accurate and clear use case.
  9. I didn't interpret that! I truly appreciate you asking for clarification, and I hope I understood your question when answering. Please don't resist (that can come out the wrong way). Also, there have been some discussions regarding walls, in principle I thought: Which is based the discussion I think you are referring to: https://wildfiregames.com/forum/topic/168544-should-units-from-siege-towers-be-able-to-ungarrison-over-walls/#comment-762718. Of course I agree with many things you say in that link, for example that "the game does not distinguish different undergrounds or soils and their respective fertility and may only have occasionally preferred/preset locations for fields (shown as "raw farmland") that (I believe) give a slight bonus to farming. Similar argumentation would possibly go for livestock stables", which I mentioned briefly in my suggestion 22 ("fertility considerations with terrain and weather") and: This could give fun situational (and civ dependent) advantages for one or the other, and added complexity by water management is open.
  10. @Grautvornix it seems that was my worst explained point (I tried to be not too detailed ). I only meant melee attacks through walls, that I think only happen with pikes, and only when both armies are squeezed on each side of a wall. I doubt changing that particular situation that I only remember happening to me once would change gameplay so much. For Palisades it could even be kept, imagining some holes on it are being made, but for the thick stone walls that's way harder to believe. Hopefully that answers your question, thanks for asking!
  11. Ahh jaja, veo que en algunas regiones es así... no en la mía :P. Creo carro de guerra estaría bien. Y haz lo que quieras con la referencia a tu amiga, es el nombre de un mapa después de todo, en teoría le puedes poner como quieras.
  12. Yes, I've also been inspired by other people, that's why I've said "have been discussed", etc, not to let their ideas be forgotten in some old thread. Nah. Enough instances of poor wording, poor reading, poor comparisons, and poor reactions
  13. Good luck , although maybe you'll fare better with small things that need fixing. I left links in each post to go back and forth the suggestions. For my part I won't be participating any more, just helping lilypoppy with his campaign from time to time, not to leave him hanging.
  14. @guerringuerrin that page is there for everyone to read, anyone can tell I'm not referring to just one comment. I've mentioned the batching stuff before, and if you want to keep shutting down criticising certain mentality as "pointing fingers", go ahead.
  15. Maybe I should have mentioned that it refers to the 4th issue mentioned in
×
×
  • Create New...