Jump to content

user1

Lobby Moderators
  • Posts

    114
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by user1

  1. I don't think the technical aspect of how to implement an automatic loss for someone who leaves a rated game is the meaningful consideration here.

    The intention of the ELO rating system is not to punish players for leaving games but instead it's meant to provide a scoring/ranking system that would hopefully, after enough games are played, represent somewhat closely the reality of which players are better than others. This is also meant to be used as a tool which can help players and the host of a match to assess players' skill level and assign balanced teams.

    The phenomenon of players leaving a rated match is usually the following case: A player realizes they're losing and so instead of allowing themselves to lose points they attempt to subvert the system so their rating will remain unchanged. This is against the rules. Reports of this are reviewed and confirmed as an instance of this happening.

    I guess it seems it wouldn't make much sense to award a win to a new player who starts a rated match with someone rated much higher but then, due to some circumstance, the match ended prematurely with points not being awarded. The new player is not a better player than the other. If rating points were to be awarded I think it would necessarily result in the rating of the new player being inflated improperly. The same can be said about players that are near to each other in skill but one is probably (at least slightly) better than the other. Awarding to someone an unearned win by giving ELO ratings points doesn't seem to make sense if one is considering the intention of the ELO system.

    I wonder if there could be a separate system (honor points of some sort?) which can be used as a demerit for bad behaviour or a reward for good behaviour, not affecting the ELO of players since otherwise it's undermining the ELO.

    • Thanks 1
  2.  

    On 18/08/2022 at 9:17 PM, Emperior said:

    Are there any rules? Expectation from the helper, such as hours per week or something? Does the player use same account or has access to new one where he does only help with lobby?

     

    Lobby helpers are still subject to the TOS, TOU, and Privacy Policy. If someone wants to be a lobby helper, there's no need for them to make some weekly or hourly commitment.

    Just volunteer yourself and serve at your leisure.

    Lobby helpers can still use their current username. No need to have multiple accounts.

     

    On 18/08/2022 at 9:07 PM, Philip the Swaggerless said:
    On 16/08/2022 at 9:19 PM, user1 said:

    I've seen numbers that suggest there might be as many players who think smurfing should be allowed as there are players who've indicated that it should not be allowed.

    Was there a poll?

    The assumption is it's reasonable to state that players who are creating multiple accounts are players who consider it ought to be allowed. And the number of players who've indicated that it should not be allowed are those that have mentioned it in chat or on the forums. This data exists already without a poll.

    On 18/08/2022 at 9:07 PM, Philip the Swaggerless said:

    The point against smurfing is that it creates unbalanced games.

    One important point is that the host is deciding whether or not to permit a smurf to play. I think it seems like that's the moment whereupon much of the bothersome effect of smurfing is generated.

    On 24/08/2022 at 3:53 PM, Norse_Harold said:

    Question: Is the conduct of a user, while in a game listed by the lobby, covered by the Terms of Use? It's not lobby chat, it's in-game chat. I think that there is an argument to be made either way, as the network packets with potentially ToU-violating speech aren't flowing through a WFG server at that point, although there is authentication through the lobby in order to connect. Can the Terms of Use be clarified to make a statement on this issue, please?

    Also, where should we report potentially bannable conduct? Do you want a PM, forum post with a mention of your name, or message via other communication system? Ideally there is a way to establish quick enforcement, but I know that those with banning admin capabilities are busy, which is probably why we're seeking more assistants.

    The lobby helpers are intended to mute a player if the chat the player has produced is breaking the terms of use. This duty can be challenging for a simple keyword-based auto mute. The hope is that the lobby helpers will be able to handle the cases that are not addressed by the auto mute. 

    The lobby helpers and lobby moderators moderate the lobby chat. While on the other hand, the services hosted by the players are moderated by those players. That is to say, each host moderates their own match.

    If you'd like, you can report things directly to me in a forum PM; that's probably the best wayth to make sure it reaches me.

    On 24/08/2022 at 7:40 PM, Norse_Harold said:

    Absence of (obvious) evidence is not evidence of absence.

    I didn't mean to imply that it's assumed there isn't some number of players who felt some way and didn't report it. I'm referring to the reports that are present in game (simple chat message in lobby) and in the forum. There are many (at least several) orders of magnitude greater number of players than there are players who have been affected enough by some thing to decide to mention it. That's what I was trying to say. It takes into consideration that there are more potential reports that were not made even though some number of players didn't like something and chose not to report it. I guess absence of evidence is also not evidence of a problem. I said it's a good thing if the majority of players like the game and the lobby.

    ProphetMuhammad is a somewhat old player. If some host is using someone's rating or their self-professed rating as a gauge of the skill of some player it's very possible that host is making an error. The host could consider taking into consideration the opinions of the rest of the players in the game, and then balance can be decided consensually.

    It's understood that many of the issues players face are because they don't like the way some host of a match runs it. Balance, allowing smurfs, allowing language, not banning some player, etc... Fortunately it's very easy now for most players to host their own match if that's their desire.  And it's easy for players to decide to join or decline to join some match for reasons they might have.

     

     

     

    • Thanks 1
  3. Some thoughts about the current state of lobby moderation:

    Smurfing wasn't noticed (as much) as a problem in the past because I was actively preventing it. But it isn't obvious that it is a severe problem here or that smurfing intrinsically is a problem in general. There have been some interesting made points about this. In fact very very few people have problem with it enough to mention anything about it. I've seen numbers that suggest there might be as many players who think smurfing should be allowed as there are players who've indicated that it should not be allowed.

    Only a handful of players have indicated smurfing as a problem to me personally (though it seems more than that have voiced it to others) while we have several thousand unique regular players. The vast majority of players are content and very much like the game and the lobby. That is a good thing.

    This is including reports of toxicity or foul language in the chat. The reports we do receive are acted on even though the opposite is said. As I mentioned before we have thousands of players and thousands of new ones added constantly. Again, with very few reports from these players. It's not unreasonable to see it as at least somewhat successful. That's not saying there isn't room for improvement but it's good to have a balanced perspective.

    Muting players is a great way to avoid possible hurt caused by the text people write in the chat while still allowing everyone to play the game. I introduced the automated muting of players because when I started as a moderator there was a big problem. 90% of swearing was not being addressed and then randomly someone would get kicked (or worse, banned). This was looking like actual moderator abuse. For me at the time I saw it as a valid criticism when it looks like everyone else can do it but if you irritate some moderator suddenly you're banned. That was indeed how it seemed. I think consistency is good.

    I'm happy to see some players interested in helping to moderate the lobby chat. This is why I have enabled for some players to help out in this area while trying to minimize the potential for moderator abuse (intentional or otherwise). This way there can be an opportunity for those players to demonstrate their wisdom and they can possibly be eventually considered for the moderator status that enables them to ban players.

    That said, the need for banning is extremely rare and because of that it's not actually important for those players to have that role. I think we have a healthy number of moderator/administrator types that are available for discussion about potentially banning some player.

    Unfortunately one of the very first players we tried out as a lobby helper turned out to have quite negative results in multiple areas but I think that just highlights that we should have not just one person but many! I would like to see the number of lobby helpers be in the dozens. It could actually end up being possible to have someone there at all times who can address some issue in the chat. 

    I have benefited by having the understanding that simply because someone has said a situation is a certain way, it doesn't necessarily mean it is so. I believe moderators and lobby helpers will benefit by having this understanding as well.

    I probably have more meaningful thoughts but that can wait for now. I haven't yet touched on rated matches.

    Please offer your thoughts on any of this. 

    Cheers :)

     

    • Like 3
  4. I can restore Christoffel-Symbol's access back into the original account if he lost access..

    It's definitely allowed multiple players from the same IP. There are thousands of players who play while sharing an IP with other players. There's no reason to warn players that they'd better not get their friends into the game if they share an IP.

    It's meant for there to be only one account for each person and there are at least several reasons for that.

     

     

    • Thanks 2
  5. There's code relevant to this. See:

    https://trac.wildfiregames.com/changeset/24728

    https://trac.wildfiregames.com/ticket/3556

    https://trac.wildfiregames.com/changeset/23374

    https://trac.wildfiregames.com/ticket/1088

    https://trac.wildfiregames.com/ticket/6136

     

    The lobby used to publish the IP address of any user hosting a match. Since 24728 the power to decide who gets the IP address has been given to the host which allows it to keep the IP address as private as it likes it to be. The lobby doesn't publish any IP address. It ought to be that using a fresh IP address and keeping it private does completely or virtually eliminate the possibility of any sort of cyber attack in general.

     

    See also:

     

    @Dizaka

    @wraitii

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
  6. Offence Reporting

    It is necessary for you to create a post on this thread detailing the incident and including the replay file.

    When reporting a player, it is mandatory to upload the correct replay.

    Instructions:

    1. Locate replay at Main Menu/Multiplayer/Replays
    2. Select replay and note replay file path.
    3. Go to path in your file manager, locate the file named "commands.txt"
    4. Upload commands.txt to the Forums (account creation required)
    5. Tag @user1
    6. Please state your lobby username and the lobby username of the offending player.

    You will not be notified of the result automatically, you may view the ongoing status of our progress at the bottom of this first post.

    Find more detailed instructions below:

    Spoiler

    First you will have to find the location on your file system where replays are stored.

    The appearance is different on every platform and also the path is different, but the concept is the same.

    The way you find this path to the location is by going to the replay selection screen and selecting (highlighting) the replay of the match you want to report. After clicking on a replay, the path will appear near the bottom of the screen. This is a screen shot of what that looks like.

    replay_path.jpg

    Inside that folder you will find 2 files. I only need commands.txt.

    The way you attach a file to the comment/reply/post is by either dragging the file from your file manager to the post, or clicking down where the 'paperclip' is where it says choose files...

    
    

     


    Progress Report:

    Spoiler
    Post Date Poster Name Report URL Replay URL Lobby Name, Reporting Player Lobby Name, Offending Player Status
    2022-01-01 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor 101942 Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-16-26.jpg
    2022-01-02 seeh link link seeh todolomeo Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-19-28.jpg
    2022-01-02 Roshan9 link link roshan9 fubar Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-42-16.jpg
    2022-01-04 Vrayer link link vrayer maharabal Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-26-28.jpg
    2022-01-04 Vrayer link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-01-04 Vrayer link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-01-06 patatevolante4 link link paul loreto1 Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-28-35.jpg
    2022-01-06 Dulac link link dulac dcm Verified 01/19/2022Screenshot_2022-01-19_10-29-29.jpg
    2022-01-06 Dulac link link dulac rayde Verified 03/15/2022
    2022-01-14 vxern link link vxern mymy Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-35-51.jpg
    2022-01-15 Dulac link link dulac princeofrusset Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-37-30.jpg
    2022-01-15 RogerDeFlor link link eldi rogerdeflor Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-38-10.jpg
    2022-01-21 draane link link draane delege88 Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-40-17.jpg
    2022-01-22 spartan299 link link spartan299 pangea Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-41-49.jpg
    2022-01-23 Vrayer link link vrayer pangea Verified 03/15/2022Screenshot_2022-03-15_11-42-13.jpg
    2022-01-30 JesterC link link jesterc falizidade Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-34-03.jpg
    2022-01-31 Vrayer link link vrayer ranging_botanist Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-35-35.jpg
    2022-02-01 Rarius link link rarius_ii 303ufo303 Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-44-30.jpg
    2022-02-01 Vrayer link link vrayer 303ufo303 Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-46-02.jpg
    2022-02-02 ssg_cheesehead link link ssg_cheesehead 303ufo303 Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-47-35.jpg
    2022-02-05 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor dreamliner Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-48-21.jpg
    2022-02-11 Beaugoux link link beaugoux pangea Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-49-27.jpg
    2022-02-17 Yekaterina link link cousin auxilentmoon Verified 03/16/2022Screenshot_2022-03-17_11-50-01.jpg
    2022-02-22 Tacoront link link basiliskos yakita Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-40-56.jpg
    2022-02-23 france1_Caramello link link france1_caramello luiskeys11 Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-43-03.jpg
    2022-02-23 Pemulis link link pemulis rakshat1 Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-52-17.jpg
    2022-02-25 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de proo Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-53-19.jpg
    2022-02-28 Tacoront link link basiliskos petreo Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-53-55.jpg
    2022-03-02 Beaugoux link link beaugoux yakita Inconclusive
    2022-03-08 Pemulis link link pemulis tinker_ Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-56-38.jpg
    2022-03-09 Publio2020 link link publio titiboi92 Verified 03/18/2022Screenshot_2022-03-18_10-58-16.jpg
    2022-03-10 Tacoront link link basiliskos noo Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-02-44.jpg
    2022-03-12 Tacoront link link     Invalid
    2022-03-13 marcelusmaximus link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-03-13 Tacoront link link basiliskos atrepar Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-03-40.jpg
    2022-03-13 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname basiliskos Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-09-38.jpg
    2022-03-13 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname obradovic Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-14-59.jpg
    2022-03-13 Beaugoux link link beaugoux reinstalled Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-52-38.jpg
    2022-03-14 e.v link link e.v sebinhas Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-54-04.jpg
    2022-03-15 e.v link link e.v pangea Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-55-22.jpg
    2022-03-16 thephilosopher link link thephilosopher wilsonwilson Verified 03/25/2022Screenshot_2022-03-25_14-55-51.jpg
    2022-03-17 AlexanDerGrosse link link alexandergrosse geschichte Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-11-10.jpg
    2022-03-17 AlexanDerGrosse link link alexandergrosse grosquick Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-11-59.jpg
    2022-03-18 zxphxr link link zxphxr barcodes Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-13-46.jpg
    2022-03-22 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de atrepar Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-14-25.jpg
    2022-03-23 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de gilgames Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-16-05.jpg
    2022-03-24 Tacoront link link basiliskos odevoradordeossos Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-17-03.jpg
    2022-03-25 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname wolfrahm Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-18-21.jpg
    2022-03-25 Beaugoux link link beaugoux chillgame Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-19-05.jpg
    2022-03-26 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname greez Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-19-39.jpg
    2022-03-27 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 rey_ragnar Verified 03/31/2022Screenshot_2022-03-31_18-20-44.jpg
    2022-03-30 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname greez Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-03-30 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname orangebiggie Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-03-30 FoodWoodBlood link link foodwoodblood atrepar Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-03-31 Pemulis link link
     
      Ratings Disabled
    2022-03-31 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname basiliskos Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-01 Pemulis link link pemulis valii Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-03 PyrrhicVictoryGuy link link pyrrhicbozo gboss Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-05 PyrrhicVictoryGuy link link pyrrhicbozo beathoven Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-07 isbara link link isbara hoi Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-07 Sevda link link islan barcodes Invalid
    2022-04-07 Emacz link link ezmac shade11 Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-10 Beaugoux link link bougeaux vallier Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-11 AlexanDerGrosse link link alexandergrosse foxooo Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-15 leopard link link leopard__ auxilentmoon Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-16 P.I.D link link p.i.d thomas13012m Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-18 seeh link link seeh nikolozi_20042 Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-20 reba. link link reba. barcodes Verified 05/19/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-21 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname petreo Inconclusive
    2022-04-23 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de baber02 Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-04-27 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname blackking Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-01 MR.MICHAEL link link catothercensor hoi Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-02 MR.MICHAEL link link catothercensor basiliskos Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-03 MR.MICHAEL link link catothercensor basiliskos Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-03 marcelusmaximus link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-05-07 1General link link 1general tomislavkranjec Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-11 seeh link link seeh sw_ Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-15 Pemulis link link pemulis hoi Verified 07/25/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-25 reba. link link reba. edoput Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-26 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname elgeneral2510 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-26 Tramite link link basiliskos hokaido Inconclusive
    2022-05-28 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor karl2011 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-29 Tramite link link basiliskos tuxmdv Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-30 brucelee link link brucelee patricius_maximus42 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-31 marcelusmaximus link link longsentenceasname peacegame Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-05-31 jegna link link jegna mrcarlos09 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-01 brucelee link link brucelee petreo Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-02 brucelee link link brucelee petreo Duplicate
    2022-06-03 brucelee link link brucelee petreo Duplicate
    2022-06-03 brucelee link link brucelee fdez Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-03 _buckethead_ link link buckethead trainmove180 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-05 Tramite link link basiliskos loreto1 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-05 _buckethead_ link link buckethead   Incorrect replay
    2022-06-06 rossenburg link link defc0n jhag09 Verified 07/26/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-10 LetswaveaBook link link letswaveabook doctororgans Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-10 1General link link 1general nz Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-13 Philadelphia link link philadelphia blackking Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-15 Tramite link link basiliskos kpitenbobzy Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-22 KpiTenBobZy link link kpitenbobzy mamasita11 Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-22 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de erator Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-23 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de fulanodetaldev Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-06-25 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor wolmer Verified 07/27/2022image.jpeg
    2022-07-23 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de garciaivo_09 Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-07-23 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor thomas13012m Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-07-24 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor auxilentmoon Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-01 seeh link link seeh petreo Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-02 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor raffut1969 Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-03 KpiTenBobZy link link kpitenbobzy loreto1 Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-03 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor todolomeo Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-13 KpiTenBobZy link link kpitenbobzy auxilentmoon Verified 08/22/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-15 Foxooo link link foxooo dokanw Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-16 Foxooo link link foxooo trainmove180 Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-17 misal link link misal mxnyy Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-17 misal link link misal mxnyy Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-19 Nympheuz link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-08-19 petiprg link link petiprg garciaivo_09 Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-20 KnightDark link link knightdark solsyah Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-20 KnightDark link link knightdark solsyah Verified 08/23/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-21 KnightDark link link knightdark auxilentmoon Processing
    2022-08-21 Nympheuz link link     Ratings Disabled
    2022-08-24 Xander12 link link     Invalid
    2022-08-24 gameraj link link gameraj jaxso2012 Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-25 Nympheuz link link nympheuz eye15 Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 mikejigsaw Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 natan412 Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 magistermiletum Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 lafenak3 Invalid
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link xander raffut1969 Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 raffut1969 link link raffut1969 johan2001 Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-26 donkenburger link link donkenburger grosquick Verified 09/03/2022image.jpeg
    2022-08-27 e.v link link e.v mbr1305  
    2022-08-28 e.v link link e.v mbr1305  
    2022-08-28 petiprg link link petiprg loreto1  
    2022-09-01 Xander12 link link xander bodospl  

     

     

     @Xander12  @gameraj  @Nympheuz   @raffut1969   @donkenburger   @e.v  @petiprg 

    • Like 4
    • Thanks 2
    • Haha 1
  7. If you have to make a report, use the following thread:


    Progress Report:

     

    Spoiler

     

    Post Date Poster Name Report URL Replay URL Lobby Name, Reporting Player Lobby Name, Offending Player Status
    2021-01-05 Thorpio link link thorpio rividelivers Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_19-38-45.jpg
    2021-01-11 gator303 link link daniel_kinq raffut1969 Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_19-41-42.jpg
    2021-01-11 Player of 0AD link link weirdjokes tato98c Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_19-44-34.jpg
    2021-01-12 gator303 link link daniel_kinq marcaurel Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_19-58-42.jpg
    2021-01-14 Bossatchal link link feilongbay mbr1305 Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_20-00-15.jpg
    2021-01-14 AALPHA link link aalpha themagiczalo Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_20-03-43.jpg
    2021-01-14 Wendy22 link link wendy doctororgans Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_19-54-34.jpg
    2021-01-17 draane link link draane mbr1305 Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_20-33-11.jpg
    2021-01-23 SuperSpartacus link link superspartacus mbr1305 Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_20-42-26.jpg
    2021-01-28 1General link link 1general jameson666 Verified 10/22/2021Screenshot_2021-10-22_20-38-42.jpg
    2021-01-31 stormwalk link link stormwalk raffut1969 Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-16-24.jpg
    2021-02-01 quierohasercaca link link quierohasercaca titiboi92 Invalid
    2021-02-01 quierohasercaca link link quierohasercaca mbr1305 Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-20-17.jpg
    2021-02-06 draane link link draane chesterxxx Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-21-36.jpg
    2021-02-08 facts link link facts miviher Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-22-20.jpg
    2021-02-09 1General link link 1general hung Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-23-07.jpg
    2021-02-19 Tristao link link basiliskos hallmayer Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-23-46.jpg
    2021-02-20 P_J link link p_j daltanius Verified 10/23/2021Screenshot_2021-10-23_16-24-44.jpg
    2021-02-24 gator303 link link daniel_king raffut1969 Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_13-45-46.jpg
    2021-03-02 seeh link link seeh princeofrusset Inconclusive
    2021-03-02 seeh link link seeh hunterkilla818 Invalid
    2021-03-05 PrincipalityOfZeon link link shade11 melusines Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_19-02-42.jpg
    2021-03-12 JoelTav link link joeltav hunterkilla818 Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_19-52-06.jpg
    2021-03-12 JoelTav link link joeltav hdonancio Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_19-52-39.jpg
    2021-03-12 Fernklang link link fernklang kkshi Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_19-53-08.jpg
    2021-03-13 gator303 link link daniel_king neb Verified 10/24/2021Screenshot_2021-10-24_19-53-55.jpg
    2021-03-15 JoelTav link link joeltav jacksparrow Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-00-28.jpg
    2021-03-15 stormwalk link link stormwalk raffut1969 Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-06-13.jpg
    2021-03-17 gator303 link link daniel_king jmnzhl Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-07-18.jpg
    2021-03-27 JoelTav link link joeltav swapnil Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-08-11.jpg
    2021-04-02 Player of 0AD link link weirdjokes letswaveabook Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-09-05.jpg
    2021-04-11 devilhook link link devilhook ninjanad Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-11-09.jpg
    2021-04-11 devilhook link link devilhook lordeder Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-12-54.jpg
    2021-04-11 devilhook link link devilhook dreamliner Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-13-47.jpg
    2021-04-15 chocapoca link link chocapoca caiomariolobi Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-23-51.jpg
    2021-04-17 luxlethor link link     Invalid
    2021-04-17 luxlethor link link luxlethor bus Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-25-14.jpg
    2021-04-18 devilhook link link     Not rated
    2021-04-18 devilhook link link     Not rated
    2021-04-19 Tomba link link tomba caiomariolobi Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-30-27.jpg
    2021-04-24 devilhook link link devilhook thedwarf Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-31-14.jpg
    2021-04-24 devilhook link link     Invalid
    2021-04-24 devilhook link link devilhook fortun Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-31-40.jpg
    2021-05-06 carthage link link     Not rated
    2021-05-06 carthage link link carthage zekooo Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-49-38.jpg
    2021-05-10 Elinvention link link supertux95 raffut1969 Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-51-25.jpg
    2021-05-11 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de 1979ad Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_12-53-03.jpg
    2021-05-16 nNeon20 link link nneon20 scatespider Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-13-39.jpg
    2021-05-20 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de tuviejaconquistadora Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-31-21.jpg
    2021-05-20 0xD3C0.de link link 0xd3c0.de tuviejaconquistadora Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-31-58.jpg
    2021-06-05 Publio2020 link link publio fortun Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-33-01.jpg
    2021-06-06 Bellaz89 link link bellanzio troll Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-33-52.jpg
    2021-06-08 Player of 0AD link link weirdjokes deivik Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-36-08.jpg
    2021-06-10 Ullsg link link ullsg indo1234 Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-37-01.jpg
    2021-06-11 alre link link alre lubacca98 Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-37-32.jpg
    2021-06-15 gandalf_deluxe link link gandolf_deluxe manonthemoon Verified 10/28/2021Screenshot_2021-10-28_13-38-07.jpg
    2021-06-22 Ullsg link link ullsg hura Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-49-17.jpg
    2021-06-23 Ullsg link link ullsg hans02 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-51-54.jpg
    2021-06-27 gandalf_deluxe link link gandolf_deluxe dreamliner Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-54-29.jpg
    2021-06-30 Tanay Rajpurohit link link     Not rated
    2021-07-06 eTrey link link etrey viabadie Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-55-37.jpg
    2021-07-07 sabatarioos link link sabatarios titosybelos Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-56-26.jpg
    2021-07-18 Kingfuzz link link kingfuzz baby-cheeses Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-57-39.jpg
    2021-07-19 carthage link link carthage nuns Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-58-06.jpg
    2021-07-22 Kingfuzz link link kingfuzz major09 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-58-34.jpg
    2021-07-27 Kingfuzz link link kingfuzz emapis Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_10-59-02.jpg
    2021-07-27 mblazev link link mblazev auxilentmoon Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-08-42.jpg
    2021-07-31 gandalf_deluxe link link     Not rated
    2021-08-07 Player of 0AD link link weirdjokes kurdistan Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-11-03.jpg
    2021-08-10 MR.MICHAEL link link mr.michael auxilentmoon Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-11-59.jpg
    2021-08-10 SwordOfSwords link link wxoop kvgyzqk Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-13-03.jpg
    2021-08-15 SwordOfSwords link link wxoop benvryl Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-21-50.jpg
    2021-08-16 Player of 0AD link link weirdjokes lubacca98 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-22-41.jpg
    2021-08-17 SwordOfSwords link link sswordlurkk captain_rsad Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-25-33.jpg
    2021-08-25 0xD3C0.de link link     Not rated
    2021-08-29 sabatarioos link link sabatarios athila37 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-42-29.jpg
    2021-09-11 gandalf_deluxe link link gandolf_deluxe aditya9812 Invalid
    2021-09-11 yano link link arewe123 rev09 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-47-48.jpg
    2021-09-14 Jofursloft link link jofursloft msg Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-54-04.jpg
    2021-09-22 gandalf_deluxe link link gandolf_deluxe nobueno Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-54-48.jpg
    2021-09-26 gandalf_deluxe link link gandolf_deluxe villano33 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-55-26.jpg
    2021-09-28 Mastoras link link mastoras hungryhippo81 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-56-44.jpg
    2021-09-28 Mastoras link link mastoras thevlasic Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-57-22.jpg
    2021-09-28 Mastoras link link mastoras malekaren Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_12-58-28.jpg
    2021-09-28 Mastoras link link mastoras pedrog Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_13-03-00.jpg
    2021-10-08 sabatarioos link link sabatarios rob_one Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-06-36.jpg
    2021-10-12 quierohasercaca link link quierohacercaca2 nothing22595 Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-07-52.jpg
    2021-10-14 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 .jairo Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-08-26.jpg
    2021-10-16 DerekO link link dereko thomas13012m Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-09-14.jpg
    2021-10-19 DerekO link link dereko fastos Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-09-48.jpg
    2021-10-21 Beaugoux link link beaugoux jmac Inconclusive
    2021-10-23 Beaugoux link link beaugoux dcm Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-13-16.jpg
    2021-10-24 Beaugoux link link beaugoux marishkakul Verified 10/29/2021Screenshot_2021-10-29_14-11-55.jpg
    2021-10-26 DerekO link link dereko mastoras  
    2021-10-26 Mastoras link link mastoras dereko Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_13-50-13.jpg
    2021-10-26 jonnyk21 link link jonnyk21 yari444 Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-13-48.jpg
    2021-10-26 DerekO link link dereko ijavaddev Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-13-17.jpg
    2021-10-26 Koceyla link link dihiya alvaradojr Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-13-48.jpg
    2021-10-27 UltraMan link link ultraman dereko Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-15-29.jpg
    2021-10-27 UltraMan link link ultraman dihiya Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-15-56.jpg
    2021-10-28 Obaky link link     Not rated
    2021-10-28 Beaugoux link link beaugoux karin_ashx Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-16-52.jpg
    2021-10-28 clavz link link clavz   Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-40-35.jpg
    2021-10-29 UltraMan link link ultraman tanmo Verified 11/08/2021Screenshot_2021-11-08_14-41-39.jpg
    2021-10-30 Obaky link link obaky emapis Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-35-08.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 vodca Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-37-02.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link mike0697 nothing22595 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-38-43.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 shalom7 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-40-04.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 empirono Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-42-20.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link nothing22595   Duplicate
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link marcelusmaximus nothing22595 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-43-17.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link eternal_blizzard nothing22595 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-44-41.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link     Not rated
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 megalodon Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_15-46-05.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link megalodon nothing22595 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_16-57-15.jpg
    2021-10-30 nothing22595 link link     Not rated
    2021-10-30 Publio2020 link link publio punfu Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_16-58-19.jpg
    2021-10-31 clavz link link clavz basiliskos Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_16-59-14.jpg
    2021-11-01 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 basiliskos Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_16-59-51.jpg
    2021-11-03 nothing22595 link link nothing22595 dajo Invalid
    2021-11-03 clavz link link     Not rated
    2021-11-04 thephilosopher link link thephilosopher thomas13012m Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_17-01-47.jpg
    2021-11-04 KatGor link link katgor fastos Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_17-02-33.jpg
    2021-11-04 draane link link draane sebastian_2402 Verified 11/13/2021Screenshot_2021-11-13_17-03-02.jpg
    2021-11-06 Al-Tocade link link al-tocade thomas13012m Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_11-56-24.jpg
    2021-11-06 Al-Tocade link link al-tocade zoldick Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-36-55.jpg
    2021-11-06 Beaugoux link link beaugoux ket.g Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-38-41.jpg
    2021-11-06 Beaugoux link link beaugoux ilias27 Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-39-31.jpg
    2021-11-08 Beaugoux link link     Not rated
    2021-11-11 Beaugoux link link beaugoux pr0siak Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-40-06.jpg
    2021-11-13 Micfild link link micfild7 fubar Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-40-44.jpg
    2021-11-13 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard egypt_man Verified 11/14/2021Screenshot_2021-11-14_12-41-05.jpg
    2021-11-13 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard nothing22595 Duplicate
    2021-11-17 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard thomas13012m Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-26-30.jpg
    2021-11-17 dzizus link link dzizus emapis Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-28-19.jpg
    2021-11-17 dzizus link link dzizus cosimo92xd Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-29-30.jpg
    2021-11-20 Volvire link link volvire winds_of_wings Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-31-13.jpg
    2021-11-22 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard manas123 Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-31-45.jpg
    2021-11-23 MR.MICHAEL link link mr.michael al-tocade Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-32-18.jpg
    2021-11-24 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard daleilama Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-32-49.jpg
    2021-11-26 MR.MICHAEL link link mr.michael dihiya Verified 11/26/2021Screenshot_2021-11-26_15-33-53.jpg
    2021-11-27 JesterC link link jesterc ranging_botanist Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-29-44.jpg
    2021-11-29 Al-Tocade link link al-tocade wolfrahm21 Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-30-50.jpg
    2021-11-29 RogerDeFlor link link rogerdeflor sardaukar Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-31-30.jpg
    2021-11-30 Xander12 link link xander ali70 Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-32-05.jpg
    2021-11-30 Xander12 link link xander dihiya Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-32-36.jpg
    2021-11-30 Xander12 link link xander idontlikeaugustus Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_11-32-58.jpg
    2021-11-30 jonnyk21 link link jonnyk21 fy Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_14-25-13.jpg
    2021-11-30 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard ali70 Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_14-26-50.jpg
    2021-12-01 seeh link link seeh madai Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_14-27-26.jpg
    2021-12-01 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard emapis Verified 12/09/2021Screenshot_2021-12-09_14-28-09.jpg
    2021-12-08 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard urbannoki Verified 12/20/2021Screenshot_2021-12-20_12-50-53.jpg
    2021-12-09 dzizus link link     Not rated
    2021-12-12 tomjtoth link link tomjtoth magus Verified 12/20/2021Screenshot_2021-12-20_12-51-24.jpg
    2021-12-17 Volvire link link volvire vovo007 Verified 12/27/2021Screenshot_2021-12-27_13-56-59.jpg
    2021-12-19 ZombieMarshmellow link link zombiemarshmellow sitting_bull Verified 12/27/2021Screenshot_2021-12-27_13-58-02.jpg
    2021-12-20 Vrayer link link vrayer pr0siak Verified 12/27/2021Screenshot_2021-12-27_13-58-51.jpg
    2021-12-21 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard delege88 Verified 12/27/2021Screenshot_2021-12-27_13-59-24.jpg
    2021-12-23 stormwalk link link stormwalk auxilentmoon Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_11-51-25.jpg
    2021-12-26 Vrayer link link vrayer ali70 Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_11-52-48.jpg
    2021-12-26 Vrayer link link vrayer ali70 Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_12-01-15.jpg
    2021-12-27 seeh link link seeh yasa.baris Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_12-01-53.jpg
    2021-12-27 seeh link link seeh   Duplicate
    2021-12-29 dzizus link link dzizus auxilentmoon Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_12-02-28.jpg
    2021-12-29 Eternal_Blizzard link link eternal_blizzard delege88 Verified 01/14/2022Screenshot_2022-01-14_12-02-58.jpg
    2021-12-30 Doc Steve link       Incomplete

     

      

    Spoiler


    replay_path.jpg

    Screenshot_2021-12-20_12-50-53.jpg

    Screenshot_2021-12-20_12-51-24.jpg

     

    • Like 3
    • Thanks 5
  8. Hi @Agni

    Can you talk more about the management work you've done? Your style, methodologies, experiences(good or bad), any PM software you may use.

    It would be nice if you could show examples or describe examples of your work. F.e. the types of products you've managed, your results, how your experience can be applied to a software project, etc..

    Do you have technical training or education in PM? Do you have a resume?

     

    [edit]

    Since we basically are working on one main product: 0 A.D., it makes sense to figure that PM (as in Product Management) could be considered essentially/effectively synonymous(at least in many ways) with PM (as in Project Management); at least for our purposes.

    The project is the product and vice-versa.

    There are resources with examples of how Product Manager differs from Project Manager (especially when an organisation has both). There would be overlapping skills and responsibilities shared by those two people in both positions(I suspect they're not very different), and the guy in one position would be well-positioned to adapt his knowledge to the other position. Those articles directly refer to the overlap between the two.

    @Agni What are your thoughts on the differences between Product Manager and Project Manager?

     

     


     

     

    • Thanks 2
  9. Hi @chadkelly thank you for taking the time to post on the forums.

    Presently you are and your account linuxxx is banned from the lobby temporarily and until further notice.

     

    Spoiler

     

    See: link has limited access

     

     

     

     

    Hopefully this can be resolved within 24 or 48 hours.

    In case the ban reason was missed:   

    18 hours ago, user1 said:

    :[17:41:07] linuxxx has been banned: Ratings abuse.

    See also: https://trac.wildfiregames.com/ticket/5679

×
×
  • Create New...